Repairing a CRS328-24p-4s+
I scored a used CRS328 for $135 which is dirt cheap for a switch that would normally be $400+. Problem is, ports 17-24 had broken PoE – so broken that RouterOS believed they were non-PoE ports. No pictures since the switch is in use.
Fortunately, the switch has three separate PoE daughterboards, one for each group of eight ports. These are not easy to remove, due to the design of the front panel of the switch. There is a cable underneath each card as well as a pin header, so be careful to not yank cables or damage any connectors. In my case, swapping the second and third caused ports 9-16 to break and 17-24 to work, so it was easy to confirm it was a bad card. If you wish to quickly install a card for testing, you don’t need to plug in the power input nor the power output – only the pin header connector to the mainboard.
Upon inspecting the failed board, I noticed that the component “FB3” seemed to have been knocked off the board. The “FB” designation would typically refer to a “ferrite bead”, but I didn’t have any surface mount ferrite beads on hand, so I replaced it with a jumper wire. Not a good long-term plan, but it was enough to get the card working, which would indicate that the missing ferrite bead was indeed the culprit. The long-term fix would be to find an appropriate replacement bead, or replace the board entirely.
April 15th, 2025 at 10:50
Matt,
Last year, I got a CRS328-24P-4S on eBay and had this exact problem with ports 1-8. This post is the only source on the Internet that I was able to find that described my issue exactly. The story came up again today and I realized I should have thanked you.
There was a ferrite bead missing on my PSE-8-W board, just like yours! Photo of the missing component: https://i.postimg.cc/q7ypG3wL/image.png
Unfortunately, it was unlabeled, but I contacted MikroTik support and was able to get out of them that “The missing component is – FERRITE BEAD 120 OHM 0603 1LN” with this link: https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/murata-electronics/BLM18SG121TN1D/1016155
I ordered a few and (after a couple of subpar attempts) was able to replace it and get PoE working on that board!
Thank you for sharing this! It got me on the right track after hours of going down too many software/firmware rabbit holes.
Logan
April 15th, 2025 at 16:11
Thank you, glad to hear I could help!